Most advice about choosing keywords assumes you'll track hundreds of them. Real life is usually smaller than that. You might be on a free plan with room for five. You might be a freelancer who wants a tight list per client that you can actually explain on a call. Or you might simply know that a list of 300 keywords never gets looked at.
A short list is a good thing. It forces you to decide what you really care about. This guide is about making that decision well: which searches earn a place, which ones to leave out, and when to swap one for another.
If you're brand new to rank tracking, our guide on how to track Google rankings covers the basics. This post picks up from there and focuses only on the choosing.
Start with the question, not the keyword
Before you open any keyword tool, write down what you want rank tracking to tell you. For example:
- “Is the new service page starting to show up?”
- “Are we holding our place for the search that brings in most enquiries?”
- “Did last month's rewrite help or hurt?”
Each keyword you track should help answer one of those questions. If a keyword wouldn't change anything you do, whether it goes up or down, it doesn't need one of your few places.
The five-slot test
Here's a simple way to fill a short list. Give each place a job.
1. The money search
Pick the one search that's closest to someone paying you. For a local service business that's usually “[service] [town]”. For a shop it's often the main product category. For a SaaS product it might be “[product type] for [audience]”.
This is the keyword you'd be most worried about if it dropped, so it's the one you most want to watch.
2. The page you're working on right now
If you've just written, rewritten or improved a page, track the main search that page is aimed at. This is how you find out whether the work is having an effect. When you're done with that page, this place can move on to the next project.
3. The “nearly there” search
Look in Google Search Console for queries where you already appear but sit somewhere around the bottom of page one or on page two. These are often the easiest wins, because Google already thinks the page is relevant. Tracking one of them tells you whether small changes, such as a better title, a clearer heading or a few internal links, are nudging it up.
4. A longer, more specific version
Short, broad searches are hard to move and often vague in intent. A longer version, such as “emergency boiler repair sunday” rather than “boiler repair”, is usually less competitive and closer to what a real customer types. It's also a fairer test of whether your page answers a specific need.
5. A brand or reputation check
Track your own brand name, or brand plus the service. It sounds obvious, but if something goes wrong, such as a directory or competitor outranking you for your own name, you want to know straight away.
You don't have to follow this exactly. The point is that every keyword has a reason to be there.
An illustrative example
This example is illustrative, not real data. Imagine a small plumbing business in Bristol with five places to fill:
- emergency plumber bristol (the money search)
- bathroom fitting bristol (a new service page they've just published)
- blocked drain clifton (appears on page two in Search Console)
- leaking radiator valve repair (a longer, specific search)
- [business name] plumbing (brand check)
Each one answers a different question. Together they give a quick, honest picture of how the website is doing, without a spreadsheet nobody reads.
What to leave out
A short list means saying no. These are usually safe to skip:
- Very broad terms you'll never realistically rank for. “Plumber” on its own is dominated by directories and big brands. Watching it won't tell you much.
- Searches with the wrong intent. If you sell a service, a search that mostly brings up “how to do it yourself” guides may never send you customers, even if you rank well.
- Near-duplicates. “plumber bristol” and “bristol plumber” usually show very similar results. Pick one.
- Keywords for pages you aren't going to touch. Tracking is most useful when you'll act on it.
Check intent before you commit
Before adding a keyword, search it yourself and look at page one. Ask:
- Are the results the same kind of page as yours (service pages, product pages, articles)?
- Are they local businesses, national brands or directories?
- Does the search show a map pack, shopping results or lots of video?
If the results look nothing like your page, ranking will be hard and may not bring the visitors you want. Choose a different search, or create the right kind of page first.
Set the right country and language
The same search can rank very differently from one country to another. If your customers are in the UK, track UK results. If you sell to Australia or Canada too, those deserve their own entry. We've written more about tracking Google rankings by country if you need it.
When to swap a keyword out
A short list should change over time. It's worth swapping a keyword when:
- the project it was tracking has finished and the position has settled;
- you've realised the search has the wrong intent;
- Search Console shows a better opportunity you weren't aware of; or
- two keywords keep showing the same page moving in the same way, so one of them isn't telling you anything new.
One thing to watch: if two of your own pages keep swapping places for the same search, that's worth looking into rather than just replacing the keyword. Our post on keyword cannibalisation explains what's going on.
When you swap, note down what you were tracking and why you stopped. A line in a notes file is enough. It makes past decisions much easier to understand later.
How often to check your short list
With only a handful of keywords, it's tempting to check every day. Rankings move around naturally, so daily checks often show noise rather than progress. Weekly is plenty for most small sites, with an extra check after a change you're waiting on. There's more on this in how often to check keyword rankings.
Where Rankline fits
I built Rankline because I wanted a simple way to see where my own websites rank without paying for a full SEO suite. Rankline Free gives you one website profile and up to five keywords, with ranking history and syncing across devices, and no card needed. That's exactly the kind of short list this guide is about.
For each keyword you choose the country and language (the UK, US, Australia and Canada are supported, in English), and Rankline shows your position, the page that's ranking and how it has changed over time. Checks run whenever you choose.
If you outgrow five keywords or need separate profiles for several sites or clients, Rankline Pro adds unlimited website profiles and keywords, bulk keyword import and CSV exports, from £8.99 for three months or £19.99 for a year. Freelancers looking after several clients might also like our page on rank tracking for SEO freelancers.
To be clear about what Rankline doesn't do: it doesn't suggest keywords, estimate search volumes, track at city level, check backlinks or run site audits. You'll still want Search Console, or a keyword research tool, to find ideas. Rankline is for keeping an eye on the ones you pick.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Questions about choosing keywords to track
How many keywords should I track?
Fewer than you think. For a small website, five to twenty well-chosen keywords usually tell you more than hundreds of loosely chosen ones. Every keyword should help you answer a question you care about.
Should I track broad keywords or long-tail keywords?
A mix, leaning towards specific ones. Broad terms are hard to move and often mixed in intent. Longer, more specific searches are closer to what customers type and show progress more clearly.
Where can I find keywords to track?
Start with Google Search Console's Performance report, which shows the searches you already appear for. Add the services or products you most want to sell, and check what customers actually type by searching yourself and looking at Google's suggestions.
Should I track my brand name?
Yes, if you have a spare place. It's a quick way to spot problems such as a directory or another site outranking you for your own name.
How often should I change the keywords I track?
Review your list every month or two, or when a project finishes. Keep the money search and brand check steady, and rotate the others as your work moves on.
Can I track the same keyword in different countries?
Yes. In Rankline you set the country and language for each keyword, so you can add the same search for the UK and, say, Australia as separate entries.
CHOOSE A USEFUL SHORT LIST
Pick a few keywords on purpose and check them steadily.
Start with one website and five carefully chosen keywords. No card needed.